Inquiries & Recommendations

Ngā ketuketutanga me ngā tūtohunga

At about 1610 on Friday, 2 October 1998, the jet boat "Terminator" was proceeding at a speed of about 65 km/h down one of many secondary channels on a braided section of the Dart River, when the driver was confronted with an obstacle partially blocking a left hand turn in the channel. As the driver attempted to make the turn around the obstruction, his boat struck it, the driver lost control and the boat skidded sideways into a shingle bank and flipped, trapping some of the passengers beneath the boat. The 11 passengers plus the driver suffered minor to serious injuries.

On Wednesday 30 September 1998, Train 823 was running from Lyttelton to Ngakawau with a rake of 18 empty coal wagons. At approximately 2340 hours the train stopped on the down main adjacent to the Middleton marshalling yard (5 km west of Christchurch) and the locomotives were then detached for servicing. A few minutes after the locomotives had cut off, the wagons started moving in an easterly direction down the grade towards Christchurch. In the course of their movement the wagons crossed two protected level crossings where insufficient warning time for road traffic was provided.

On Thursday, 24 September 1998, at about 1710, the restricted-limit passenger catamaran "Scat Cat" foundered off Mokoia Island in Lake Rotorua. The vessel had been on a one-hour sight-seeing tour with two crew and seven passengers, including four children, on board. The passengers and crew abandoned the vessel and were rescued from lifefloats by two speedboats, one belonging to the owner of "Scat Cat" and the other to a colleague. One three-year-old passenger was detained in hospital overnight for observation for hypothermia. There were no other injuries.

On Monday 14 September 1998 at about 1152 hours, ZK-DKL, a Cessna 177B Cardinal on an air transport scenic flight across the Mount Cook region struck a snow-covered mountain face 11 km north-east of Mount Cook. The pilot and two passengers died as a result of the impact.

On Thursday, 10 September 1998, an on-track maintenance group had just finished packing up their two hi-rail vehicles for off-tracking when they noticed Train GR7, the EM80 track evaluation car, approaching from the north and approximately 2.7 km distant. The ganger managed to contact the locomotive engineer using the train control radio and the train was brought to a stop well clear of the hi-rail vehicles. The cause of the near collision was the drawing of a maintenance occupation on the train control diagram approximately 10 km south of its actual location.

At about 1710 on Saturday, 5 September 1998, the passenger sailing vessel "Phantom of the Straits" was engaged on a short sailing trip on Wellington Harbour when fire broke out near the engine enclosure. The fire was eventually extinguished, but not before the vessel had suffered extensive fire and smoke damage below decks. The skipper suffered from minor smoke inhalation; otherwise none of the four passengers or deck-hand were injured in the fire. Factors contributing to the fire included substandard features in the electrical and machinery installations on board the yacht.

[A preliminary investigation showed that the circumstances were not likely to have significant implications for transport safety. Consistent with section 13 of the TAIC Act the Commission discontinued the investigation and no report was published.]

On Wednesday, 25 August 1998 a number of 3.7 m long logs fell from the last wagon of a rake of loaded log wagons in Mount Maunganui railway yard. The loss of load occurred because the logs were not adequately restrained by the cradle supports at either end. A safety issue identified was the adequacy of the code covering the securing of 3.7 m logs on standard log wagons. The Commission investigated this incident because of the potential for displaced logs to endanger other trains and third parties adjacent to the track.

On Wednesday 19 August 1998, Cessna 402C aeroplane ZK-VAC was on a scheduled flight from Stewart Island to Invercargill when both engines failed. After the successful ditching in Foveaux Strait five passengers were rescued, but three passengers and the pilot, who were without lifejackets, did not survive. One passenger is missing presumed dead. The cause of the double engine failure was not conclusively established but may have been associated with systemic fuel management. Safety issues identified included:

On Tuesday, 18 August 1998 at about 1845 the passenger cargo vessel "Stella" had an apparent loss of steering in heavy weather when attempting to turn around and head out of Omaha Bay. The vessel was on passage from Tryphena to Auckland with three persons on board. Due to a navigational error the "Stella" approached Omaha Bay although intending to approach the Auckland main channel. The "Stella" was held approximately in position under tow by the vessel Great Barrier Express. "Stella" was towed to the shelter of Bon Accord Harbour by HMNZS Kahu.

At about 1525 hours on 17 August 1998 a group of secondary school students were crossing the Henderson rail yard at the south end. A cyclist in the group dismounted to cross the rails, and while pushing his bicycle fell in front of train 2125, a southbound diesel multiple unit passenger train. The youth received serious injuries requiring amputation of one leg.

On Thursday, 13 August 1998, at about 0120, the fishing vessel "San Rakaia" grounded on Ninepin Rock at the entrance to Pelorus Sound. The vessel had been on passage from Nelson to the Cook Strait fishery with seven persons on board. There were no injuries. With assistance of other vessels the "San Rakaia" was refloated on the next high tide. Safety issues identified included: • inadequate management of the crew working routine, leading to fatigue • under utilisation of available navigation aids • lack of a watchkeeper monitor alarm for single-handed bridge operation